That's not what Smokey Robinson said? It's "I Second That Emotion"? Ah, that's a whole nother thing, innit? Nevertheless, it seems to me that there are two main emotions men are allowed to express in American society: Anger and Love, both of which have been bastardized/co-opted/corrupted and turned on their heads from what they should mean.
Anger is the single most common emotion that we expect/accept from our men. We're (white guys) almost expected to be angry today, mostly because the power and influence we have wielded since the dawn of "civilized" society is on the way out. Women, blacks, black women, Latinos and Latinas are stepping forward to assert themselves and their relevance to our national discourse, and we white guys, especially the late middle-aged ones, don't especially like that. The world was ours, and we see it slipping away.
The Tea Party is one prime illustration of this, for me. They want to return to those thrilling days of yesteryear, and just can't get their heads around the fact that things have changed. The Wall Street Journal, of all places, has characterized their orchestration of the current government shutdown as "a full-on charge into fixed bayonets." And yes, I know that there are lots of women who belong to the TP (hmmm, "TP," huh?) and even hold positions of leadership and spokesmanship (no gender-correct terms for those babes), but all that does is put me in mind of East German (nominal) Women's Olympic teams: the chromosome counts were always off, and I'd bet the same would be true for TP women.
So there's that, the anger of those-in power-but-soon-to-be-dispossessed, but there's also Love; men are allowed to show it, but only from a position of strength: we can say we love in a possessive way, but we can't show need. "I love that bitch, but only when she toes a line I define." We can't show angst, or anxiety, or grief, or fear, or despair; those are all valid emotions (oh, Possible-All-Powerful-Being, I've lapsed into Therapspeak), but they're not for Real Men (wow, didn't I hit the capital "R" and capital "M" hard, there). The all-giving, all-accepting form of Love which women have been conditioned to provide ever since god stopped being a woman is not ours to give. "We'll give 'Love,' but only on our terms" seems to be the best we can do.
Anyway, this was meant to be a commentary on the current crisis in our "government," a look at how men have devolved into second-class (at best) emotional beings, and an examination, again, of gender-defined roles. Instead, due to to time/intellectual capability constraints, it's just whatever I could put together. Someday, when I have lots 'o' time, I'll write something good. I promise. Anyway, here's the playlist for this week:
True Emotion Jennifer Warnes
Sweet Emotion Aerosmith
Show Some Emotion Joan Armatrading
Real Emotions Los Lonely Boys
Mixed Emotions Rolling Stones
I Second That Emotion Smokey Robinson & The Miracles
Emotional Rescue Rolling Stones
Emotional Weather Report Tom Waits
I Second That Emotion Jerry Garcia/Merl Saunders
Emotionally Yours Bob Dylan
I'm Not Feeling It Anymore Van Morrison
I've Got A Feeling Fabs
Feelin' Alright Joe Cocker
Goin' Down The Road Feelin' Bad Grateful Dead
Prelude/Angry Young man Billy Joel
Mean, Angry, Nasty And Lowdown Shirley Scott
I'm Not Angry Elvis Costello
Angry Eyes Loggins & Messina
Angry Blues James Taylor
The Angry Monk Tony Furtado/American Gypsies
An Angry Blade Iron & Wine
Remember John Lennon
This Wheel's On Fire The Band
FYI: Lennon's "Remember" references "the fifth of November," Guy Fawkes Day, in memory of the fellow (can't say "guy," right?) who wanted to blow up Parliament; I don't get why we're not all marching on Washington with torches, pitchforks, tar & feathers to clean out the House of Reps. and get things moving again. Emily Dickinson said that "hope is the thing with feathers...;" she just left out the tar.
Women.
"The all-giving, all-accepting form of Love which women have been conditioned to provide ever since god stopped being a woman is not ours to give."
ReplyDeleteThat line wins. Was there once the cultural infrastructure for men to express the [presently] unacceptable emotions for Real Men? Men publicly expressing vulnerability in my mind only happens at AA and maybe sometimes in church. And I guess at the bar now and again after a few whiskeys?
This may have been "just" "whatever I could put together" but I appreciated the reflection. There. I've commented and broken my lurking silence.
I don't suppose there's a way to listen to your radio show through a podcast (ie. when I'm driving to or from New Haven on Wednesday)
Hey, J.A. (let's preserve your relative anonimity):
DeletePodcasts don't exist. There's no money for them at our little station; we can barely (somehow) cover the royalties paid to artists for one play of their songs, never mind dozens. But I record all of my shows, and I'd be happy to give them all to you, to do with what you will.
Sounds good. I'll bring a flash drive next time i come over.
DeleteWill you run for POTUS?
ReplyDeleteThat always sounds dirty to me. And I'm dumb, but I'm not crazy.
Delete